lib/components/track_tile/track_options.dart

@@ -102,7 +102,7 @@ class TrackOptions extends HookConsumerWidget {
             },
             leading: const Icon(SpotubeIcons.queueAdd),
             title: Text(context.l10n.add_to_queue),
-          )
+          ),
         else
           ButtonTile(
             style: ButtonVariance.menu,

lib/provider/audio_player/audio_player.dart

@@ -230,10 +230,21 @@ class AudioPlayerNotifier extends Notifier<AudioPlayerState> {
         .filter(tracks)
         .toList();
 
+    final remainingTracks = state.tracks.where(
+        (track) =>
+            allowDuplicates ||
+            !addableTracks.any((element) => _compareTracks(element, track))
+    )
+    .toList();
+
+    state = state.copyWith(
+      tracks: [...addableTracks, ...remainingTracks],
+    );
+
     for (int i = 0; i < addableTracks.length; i++) {
       final track = addableTracks.elementAt(i);
 
-      final (currentTrackIndex, _) = state.tracks
+      final (currentIndex, _) = remainingTracks
           .indexed
           .cast<(int, SpotubeTrackObject?)>()
           .firstWhere(
@@ -246,13 +257,13 @@ class AudioPlayerNotifier extends Notifier<AudioPlayerState> {
 
       final newIndex = max(state.currentIndex, 0) + i + 1;
 
-      if (allowDuplicates || currentTrackIndex < 0) {
+      if (allowDuplicates || newIndex < 0) {
         await audioPlayer.addTrackAt(
           SpotubeMedia(track),
           newIndex
         );
       } else {
-        await audioPlayer.moveTrack(currentTrackIndex, newIndex);
+        await audioPlayer.moveTrack(currentIndex, newIndex);
       }
     }